Ethnobotanical Leaflets 14: 626-41, 2010.
Documentation
and Analysis of Certain Macrofungal Traditional Practices from Western-India
(
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Botanical Name (Acronym)/(Family) |
Native Name |
Preparation and Usage |
|
TEMPs from Jessore
Community (JC) |
|||
|
1 |
Xylaria (Xy) unknown species (Clavariaceae) |
More-pankh (peacock feather) |
It is used in diseases like pneumonia, constipation, and eczema. It is also used to treat children suffering pneumonia or pneumonia like symptoms. Around 5 to 6 entire fruiting bodies are triturated fresh with water for several times to form a uniform paste. The paste is consumed orally for pneumonia or constipation but is applied topically for eczema. Generally for pneumonia 1 tablespoon is administered for 3-5 times on different days. For sever constipation same dose is given after dinner for 2 to 3 days. In case eczema the affected area is covered with the paste and bandaged. This is repeated till recovery is evident. |
|
2 |
Coprinus comatus (Cc) (Coprinaceae) |
Ajjio |
It is mostly used for skin related diseases like lesions, bruised and infected skin, or for wound healing. The part of the fruiting body used in these cases is the cap and not the stipe. To be more specific the cap is opened and the spore bearing gills are applied to the affected area directly, which is then bandaged. It can be said that the spores are given the prime importance. The spores are applied till the healing is considerable. |
|
3 |
Phallus (Ph) unknown species (Phallaceae) |
Datto (button) |
The cap is crushed in mortar with water and applied on wound, skin infections, boils, or lesions but is not bandaged. The application is repeated twice everyday for 3 days or longer if needed. |
|
4 |
Lepiota cristata (Lp) (Clavariaceae) |
Chatri (umbrella) |
The entire mushroom is crushed in mortar and applied on the boils to speed its maturation and the regression. One or two applications are sufficient to treat. |
|
5 |
Scleroderma (Sc) Unknown species (Sclerodermatales) |
Dado (ball) |
One or 2 fruit bodies are applied topically only for physical afflicted wounds. The gleba is triturated in water and applied over wounds and bandaged. The same is repeated for 2 to 3 times or till total recovery is confirmed. |
|
TEMPs from Purna Community
(PC) |
|||
|
6 |
Termitomyces tyleranus (Tt) (Pleuteaceae) |
Adim |
It is dried and used for prophylaxis throughout the year for general protection against diseases or with special reference to chicken pox. Also burned and inhaled to speed up the occurrence, maturation and scaling of chicken pox. Cooked or raw mushrooms are consumed orally. |
|
7 |
Phellinus durissimus (Pd) |
Galpacodio (addressing mumps) |
Generally they (7 to 11) are triturated in water and applied on mumps affected edema, fruiting body heated and padded on simple edema or inflammation; used for mastitis or initial boils; also used to pace up the full occurrence of chicken pox by inhaling heated or partially burned fruiting bodies on fire. Application for 1-2 times is said to be sufficient. |
|
8 |
P. linteus (PL) |
||
|
9 |
P. rudis (Pr) |
||
|
10 |
P. merrillii (Pm) |
||
|
11 |
P. robinea ( |
||
|
12 |
Unidentified macrofungi (Rd) |
Lal bhuko (red powder) |
Applied on lesions, edema, boils, mastitis, rashes, bruised skin infection, pimples, impetigo, pustules, fissures, any inflammation or wound healing purpose. Spore mass applied in water or oil base 1-2 times. |
|
13 |
Bovista (Bv) unknown species (Lycoperdacea) |
Bhupid |
The spore mass used as topical application on bruised skin infections directly till recovery. |
|
14 |
Dictiophora (Dp) unknown species (Phallaceae) |
Jaadi (net) |
Topical application of spores on edema or any kind of inflammation as a sure shot is claimed. Practitioners have so much faith that in its absence soil bearing mycelia is also used. |
|
15 |
Pleurotus (Pt) unknown species (Pleurotaceae) |
- |
It is said to impart strengthening effect when consumed orally after cooking. |
|
16 |
Lentinus (L1) unknown species (Lentinaceae) |
Vansarta (growing on bamboo) |
It is a prized edible mushroom in the locality and is consumed without the stipe. It is consumed after proper cooking as it is believed to be hard to digest. It is stored through the year as powder and added in soups for better health. It is also used specifically during convalescence. |
|
17 |
Lentinus (L2) unknown species (Lentinaceae) |
- |
It is harder to chew and hence is less preferred. Properly cooked stipeless dried powdered mushrooms are orally consumed for strength. It is also sometime known to cause nausea and stomach ache. |
|
18 |
Termitomyces (Tu) unknown species (Tricholomataceae) |
Adim |
It is consumed orally for general good health. |
|
19 |
Termitomyces microcarpus (Tm) (Tricholomataceae) |
Sita-adim (small adim) |
|
|
20 |
Unidentified (Kk) |
Kulambi-kunwar (Cloumn like, prince) |
They (No. 19 to 23) are consumed to attain good health specifically during the monsoon or during convalescence. |
|
21 |
Unidentified (Rk) |
Raj-kunwar (royal prince) |
|
|
22 |
Termitomyces (Rb) unknown species (Tricholomataceae) |
Rombadia |
|
|
23 |
Termitomyces (Ra) unknown species (Tricholomataceae) |
Rombadia-adim |
|
Types of ailments treated with macrofungi
JC
engaged macrofungi entailing treatment regimes for pneumonia, constipation, eczema, bruised skin
infection, lesion, boils and wound healing. Whereas, PC employed macrofungi
species for immune enhancement required in specific diseases apart from
addressing ailments like bruised skin infection, edema, mumps, measles,
chickenpox, mastitis, boils, wound healing, rashes, lesions, pimples,
impetigo, pustules, fissure and inflammation in general, employing
macrofungi. The latter community was found to address a wider range of
ailments countered by TEMPs.
Relevance of Species and its TEMPs
Cc (Ershova et al., 2001; Efremenkova et al., 2003; Yang et al., 2003; Fan et al., 2006; Luo et al., 2004; Badalyan et al., 2003) and PL (Chen et al., 2006; Kim et al., 2005; Yeon et al., 2008) are the only species for which substantial amount of
bioprospecting and bioactivity is already done. Two separate species
belonging to the genus of Tt are reported to have antioxidant (Puttaraju et al., 2006) and neuritogenic (Qi et al., 2001) activities, which are
not directly related to the TEMPs recorded by us. TEMP related activity of Dictyophora indusiata, a species dissimilar to local variety Dp, is reported to posses
anti-inflammatory effects attributed to (1→6)-branched (1→3)-β-D-glucan (Hara et al., 1982). This corroborates well with
the local TEMP (Table 1, No. 14) thought it seems to be a different species. TEMP of Bv was reported for other species used for healing abscess and
other wounds in animals (Lans et al., 2007). Pm is known to possess antioxidant activity that may be an integral
part underlying its TEMP (Chang et
al., 2007). Rest of the TEMPs and
the species are reported here for the first time to the best of our
knowledge.
Informant Consensus of TEMPs
Consensus indexing has been widely practiced for evaluating the reliability of the traditional knowledge. Most of the ailments treated by the Purna community had a better informant’s consensus index than the Jessore community. PC used a total of 18 species for various ailments but JC employed only 5 species. Jessore is in the North of the state at the border of Rajasthan and has many dunes with patches of sparse forest on hills as it receives very scanty rainfall. Purna is located in the southern region of the state, which has dense dry deciduous forests and receives heavy rainfall. This geo-climatic difference can influence the density and the diversity of macrofungi available in a particular geographical location and can leave the traditional practitioner with meagre resources than others with access to a greater biodiversity.
Any-how, such factors may not be the final arbitrators because the quality of know-how may have fewer but rarer significant practices within the limited resources with respect to the varying ecological niches. Good consensus values should be a help in identifying the important species. Thus, such a marker that can attach a range of values to evaluate the reliability of the traditional knowledge can be of great importance for pharmacological research as well. The credibility of the consensus analysis regarding both the aspects in TEMPs was assessed for the current small and mixed knowledge pool.
The analysis of Fic (Informant’s consensus index factor) revealed varied outputs (Table 2). The values were high for most of the ailments ranging from 0.9 to 0.928, except three ailments, which gave erroneous results due to only 1 report causing the denominator to be 0. In PC, 11 diseases scored the maximum indicating no options to the species employed, but 2 ailments were low scoring with several options. Certain scores ran into negative figures because they had more number of species (Nt) and lesser number of reports (Nur). The multiplicity of species is due to superficially indistinguishable closely related macrofungal species, which is common for polypores of the same genus. Such may not be the case with plants. Some times several species of a genus may be closely associated chemotaxons. Thus either of them may serve the purpose as the active compound may be conserved in most of them. Pharmacologists screening for such active molecules can isolate it from either of them, but in such case Fic can be misleading as it remains unattended by the consensus paradigm.
|
Ailment |
Nur |
Nt |
Fic |
|
JC |
|||
|
Pneumonia |
1 |
1 |
∞ |
|
Constipation |
1 |
1 |
∞ |
|
Eczema |
1 |
1 |
∞ |
|
Bruised skin infection |
14 |
2 |
0.923 |
|
Lesion |
12 |
2 |
0.909 |
|
Boils |
11 |
2 |
0.9 |
|
wound healing |
15 |
2 |
0.928 |
|
PC |
|||
|
Immune-stimulation |
14 |
1 |
1 |
|
Bruised skin infection |
15 |
2 |
0.923 |
|
Edema |
3 |
6 |
-1.5 |
|
Mumps |
3 |
6 |
-1.5 |
|
Measles |
3 |
5 |
-1 |
|
Chickenpox |
3 |
6 |
-1.5 |
|
Mastitis |
1 |
6 |
∞ |
|
Boils |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
Wound healing |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
Rashes |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
Lesions |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
Pimples |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
Impetigo |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
Pustules |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
Fissure |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
Inflammation |
15 |
7 |
0.57 |
|
Convalescence |
15 |
1 |
1 |
|
Good-health / Strength |
15 |
11 |
0.286 |
The negative values also show closed knowledge pool causing lesser or single reports for Nt > Nur (number of species > reports), which is also true for Nur = 1 and hence Fic = infinity. Thus all values below zero belong to closed knowledge pool, but for Nur > Nt closed pools are also possible. Fic is impaired for smaller studies, as Nur has to be > 1 and Nt has to be > Nur to get only positive values. Moreover, due to ecological challenges like habitat erosion and species dilution, the effective species might become rare, which will stress the practices and can have two possibilities. If no alternates are available then traditional knowledge might become extinct as well because of the lack of practice over generations. In such cases of rare practices, Nur may be 1 and Fic will be ∞. If several alternates to the species are available then another possibility arises, wherein Nt may be high due to dilution of know-how. The Fic value is indifferent to such cases.
Use of each species for multiple symptoms of the same ailment may cause higher Nt which can be deceptive as Fic will be low. The Consensus value is rigid as all the plants used for the illness are treated equally as they may have lower or higher efficacy. Thus dynamic treatment is needed which treat all the species as case-to-case basis. The identification of the most effective species of several options for a particular ailment is the target for molecular investigations.
For objectives like drug discovery consensus value may be deceptive as one of the several species may be very effective, but will be enshrouded by other species causing low consensus value. Thus, preference given to one species over others can mark its greater efficacy over others and has to be incorporated in the estimates.
Moreover, if one species is used in different illnesses which are alike then the community knowledge may not have discrepancy but will have lower richness as lesser numbers of species are used for more diseases. Thus, not only the health but the wealth of the community knowledge is important as well but this is not addressed by Fic. Hence, this analysis is not very successful in the current scenario and yet other need based analysis addressing other variables is required. Such factors can be used to segregate the practices or species. Hierarchical agglomerative clustering can be one such simple tool.
Clustering analysis
Some excellent studies on the cultural significance of the mushrooms (Garibay-Orijel et al., 2007; Pieroni, 2001) seemed to be from open knowledge pool as the know-how of species usage was common. Moreover, the application of such species was mostly addressing general health remedies. The present study differed in both the aspects. The knowledge pool and the practices or application of species within a particular community is found to be an admixture of both situations. In addition to this, the aim of the study also differed as identifying the corner-stone species was essential as explained above. The tailored observations addressing the current requirements were made to segregate the species based on three aspects of usage and know-how, which could easily isolate the corner-stone species.
The species used for specific
practices attending a particular critical-ailment is more precious than those
used for general (non-critical) purposes as strength giving and recovery from
illness. It was observed during the study that the know-how of such species
employed for specific ailments were known by few practitioners, some of them
being traditional medical practitioners, immobilized the knowledge. This
caused the existence of the closed knowledge pool co-existing with the open
knowledge pool. Thus such species can said to be more important regarding
medicinal values than the general ones. Species stored for later use were
found to be important, and hence needed to have preeminence over others.
Hierarchical agglomerative clustering of species based
on the presence or absence of three factors mentioned above revealed a
typical clustering pattern (Figure 2) with group-average linking rule
generating best cophenetic correlation coefficient (0.9968) and delta value
(at 0.5, 0.035; at1.0, 0.052). The 1st cluster (Rk, Kk, Tm, Tu,
RA, R and Pt) separated at distance value of 1 of total 6 minor clusters. The
2nd cluster had L2 and L1 (distance value 0.9) as outliers to the
3rd cluster. Sc, Lp, Ph and Cc separated from the rest at 0.77,
where 3 minor clusters were observed. Tt (0.65) was outlying a cluster of Rd,
In comparison with the Jessore the Purna community revealed several significant TEMPs, though both the communities contribute to usages reported for the first time. The mention of TEMPS involving species like Xy, Ph, Lp and Sc from JC and Tt, Rd, Bv, Pd, Pr, Po, Pm and Dp from PC are novel.
Preliminary bioprospecting by simple binary clustering could characterize the species-practice data matrix, wherein the edible mushrooms used for non-specific ailments can be potential sources of nutraceuticals. Other species addressing specific ailments will be further studied for their pharmaceutical potential. Fic gave ambiguous results which can be attributed to several reasons like non-plant study, heterogeneous knowledge pool (closed and open) and comparatively smaller subject size. Herein, the health (reliability) of the community knowledge was better depicted by multiple factors/markers, rather than single Fic value, which was useful in capturing the wealth (richness) of community knowledge as well. Fishing of promising practices from the pool of vague practices could be grossly achieved to an extent, which for fine tuning at the level of individual species will need more number of markers. for a detailed pharmacological evaluation such an analysis , will be useful in identifying few potent species from a big database.
The work is funded by Gujarat Council on Science and Technology under the project GUJCOST/MRP/2004-05/200419. We heartily thank Mr. Pradeep Khanna and other officials of Department of Forest and the traditional knowledge practitioners, for permitting, co-operating and encouraging the study.
Badalyan, C.M., Gasparyan, A.V., Garibyan,
N.G. 2003. Investigation of the
antioxidant activity of some basidial macromycetes.
Chang, H.Y., Ho, Y.L., Sheu, M.J., Lin, Y.H., Tseng, M.C., Wu, S.H., Huang, G.J., Chang, Y.S. 2007. Antioxidant and free radical scavenging activities of Phellinus merrillii extracts. Botanical Studies 48: 407 - 417.
Chang, H.Y., Peng, W.H., Sheu, M.J., Huang, G.J., Tseng, M.C., Lai, M.T., Ho, Y.L. 2007. Hepatoprotective and Antioxidant Effects of Ethanol Extract from Phellinus merrillii on carbon tetrachloride-induced liver damage. Am. J. Chinese Med. 35: 793 - 804.
Chen, W., He, F.Y., Li, Y.Q. 2006. The apoptosis effect of hispolon from Phellinus linteus (Berkeley & Curtis) Teng on human epidermoid KB cells. J. Ethnopharmacology 105; 280 - 285.
Efremenkova OV,
Ershova EY, Zenkova VA, Tolstych IV, Dudnik YV: Antimicrobial activity of
medicinal macrofungi from the genus Coprinus
(Fr.) S. F. Gray (Agaricomycetideae). Intl.
J. Med. Mush. 2003,
Ershova, E.Y., Efremenkova, O.V., Zenkova, V.A., Tolstych, I.V., Dudnik,
Y.V. 2001.The revealing of antimicrobial activity
of strains of the genus Coprinus.
Fan, J., Zhang, J., Tang, Q., Liu, Y., Zhang, A., Pan, Y. 2006. Structural elucidation of a neutral fucogalactan from the mycelium of Coprinus comatus. Carbohydr. Res. 341: 1130 - 1134.
Garibay-Orijel,
R., Caballero, J., Torres, A.E., Cifuentes, J. 2007. Understanding cultural
significance the edible macrofungi case. J.
Ethnobio. Ethnomed. 3: 1 - 18.
Hara, C., Kiho, T., Tanaka, Y., Ukai, S. 1982. Anti-inflammatory activity and conformational behavior of a branched from an alkaline extract of Dictyophora indusiata Fisch. Carbohydr. Res. 110: 77 - 87.
Hawksworth, D.L. 2001. Macrofungi: the extent of the unexplored potential. Int. J. Med. Mush., 3: 333 - 337.
Hintze, J.L. 2007. NCSS, PASS, GESS. NCSS Kaysville, Utah, U.S.A.
Kim, J.D., Kim, M.B., Lee, J.S. Composition for treatment and prevention of cold comprising extract of African Phellinus linteus mushroom inhibiting influenza virus by antiviral effect and immunity enhancement. Kongkae Taeho Kongbo 2005, Chem. Abstr. 145: 299539.
Lahiri, S.K., Shukla, M.D., Modi, H.A.
2008. An estimate of mushroom biodiversity and datasheet preparation for
documentation of tribal know-how of macrofungi from
Lahiri, Suman, De A.B. 2007. Record of Phellinus Quel. from
Lans, C., Turner, N., Khan, T., Brauer,
G. 2007. Ethnoveterinary medicines used for ruminants in
Pegler, D.N. 1986. Agric Flora of
Pieroni, A. 2001. Evaluation of the
cultural significance of wild food botanicals traditionally consumed in
Puttaraju, N.G., Venkateshaiah, S.U.,
Dharmesh, S.M., Urs, S.M., Somasundaram, R. 2006. Antioxidant activity of
indigenous edible macrofungi. J Agric
Food Chem 54: 9764 - 9772.
Qi, J., Ojika, M., Sakagami, Y. 2001. Neuritogenic cerebrosides
from an edible Chinese mushroom. Part 2: Structures of two additional
termitomycesphins and activity enhancement of an inactive cerebroside by
hydroxylation. Bioorg. Med. Chem.
9: 2171 - 2177.
Subramanyam, R.,
Newmaster, S.G. 2009. Valorizing the 'Irulas' traditional knowledge
of medicinal plants in the Kodiakkarai Reserve Forest, India. J. Ethnobio. Ethnomed.
Wasson, R.G.
1971. Soma: Divine Mushroom of Immortality,
Ethnomycology Studies No.1, Harvest special, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New
York, U.S.A.
Yang, X., Wan, M., Mi, K., Feng, H.,
Chan, D.K.O., Yang, Q. 2003. The
quantification of (1, 3)-β-glucan in edible and medicinal mushroom
polysaccharides by using limulus G test. Mycosystema
22: 296 - 302.
Yeon, S., Kang, Y.H., Jung, J.Y., Kang, I.J., Han, S.N., Chung, J.S., Shin, H.K., Lim, S.S. 2008. Inhibitory constituents of aldose reductase in the fruiting body of Phellinus linteus. Biol. Pharmaceutical Bull. 31: 765 - 768.